American Football / NFL

Will the Raiders Regret the Matt Flynn Trade?

If you follow me on twitter, you’ll know what my answer to that question is already.

I’m puzzled, to be quite honest. Really puzzled.

The Raiders already have a limited amount of picks, they’ll have to have given up a fairly high pick for the backup who has started two games in his career, both towards the end of seasons when there wasn’t much to play for.

I hate the idea of trading for a backup, because there will always be a quarterback better than him in the NFL. He’ll be limited in what he can do, which means a much lower ceiling than a quarterback picked in the NFL Draft.

The potential draft pick who Flynn was picked instead of was Geno Smith, a West Virginia product who will almost certainly be the first quarterback taken in April’s draft.

Smith has a ton of potential, and with the right setup will be one of the better quarterbacks in the league eventually. Do I ever think Flynn will reach those heights? No. Not at all.

Cast your mind back to this time last year. Remember the Miami Dolphins being “nailed on” to sign Flynn as he’d worked with the new Dolphins head coach Joe Philbin. Philbin worked with Flynn for several years and probably knew him better than any other person in the league.

So what did the Dolphins do? They passed on Flynn. The national media were dismayed by this “typical Dolphins” move. Instead, a quarterback from Texas A&M labelled a “project” by experts was selected, someone who had no chance to start in Miami and had a high chance of becoming a bust apparently. Now lets look at the move from the viewpoint of March 2013. Experts.

Jeff Ireland and Joe Philbin passed on Matt Flynn because they knew he was limited. They knew that Ryan Tannehill’s ceiling was higher and that he had all the tools to succeed. Flynn does not.

Geno Smith is a similar prospect to Ryan Tannehill, he’s been rated higher coming out of college, but just like Tannehill he has the tools to succeed. The Raiders are settling for mediocre when they could have great. Obviously there are no guarantees that Smith will be great, but who do you think is more likely to become great, Smith or Flynn?

Final point: Tell me a team that traded for a quarterback in recent years that has won the Super Bowl? The Manning-Rivers draft day trade doesn’t count.

Good luck, Raiders fans.


7 thoughts on “Will the Raiders Regret the Matt Flynn Trade?

  1. naturally like your web site but you have to test the spelling on quite a few of your posts. Many of them are rife with spelling problems and I find it very bothersome to inform the reality then again I will surely come back again.

    • Can you point out my spelling problems? Spell check says that my spelling is fine, although I’ve probably made a load of grammatical errors. I’m not going to spend too much time fretting over spelling and grammatical errors when the site is still developing, as long as the general content is good.

  2. Matt Schaub has not worked badly for the Texans, has he? He’s certainly good enough to win a SB for them.

    Besides, the Raiders have lots of needs. Drafting a QB who does not seem to have the talent for the 1 round just because you need a QB is not a good decision. Flynn may be a decent servicable QB who does not cost much.

    The general rule is you draft the best player remaining in the draft, there likely won’t be a single QB in the first round that matches this rule. I don’t know who the Raiders should and will draft, but I would trust the new GM more. He appears to be a no-nonsense guy who can correctly ascertain the true value of a player.

    • I disagree big time on the final paragraph, Geno Smith is worthy of a top 5 pick and I know that many “experts” agree with me.

      • Many experts also disagree with you. Geno Smith looks to be very raw, and a lot of people don’t think he has the talent to succeed in the NFL.

      • True. I’m a die-hard Geno believer though, and his tools and skillset are similar to that of Ryan Tannehill coming out. As a Dolphins fan I personally think some are setting themselves up for a Tannehill style miss on a prospect again.

    • Also: I actually think Matt Schaub is holding the Texans back, that roster is loaded and he still can’t get past the Patriots. TJ Yates basically played just as well as he did when we was out injured in 2011.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s